More Solutions Sought in Spill Response

By Ian Graham

Though BP has successfully placed a cap over the leaking oil valve in the Gulf of Mexico, the federal government’s Interagency Alternative Technology Assessment Program, a new workgroup established by Coast Guard Adm. Thad Allen, the National Incident Commander for the Deepwater Horizon oil spill. Allen, is seeking innovative solutions that could help stop the oil spill or assist in cleanup operations.

The cap installed this week is “one step back from the best cap we can get,” Allen said in a press conference, not a permanent solution. The admiral said that it is a positive step toward halting the spill completely, but more help is needed.

For more information on submitting ideas, click “More” at the bottom of this post.



From a Deepwater Horizon Incident Joint Information Center press release:

The Coast Guard’s Research and Development Center, in collaboration with interagency partners, issued a Broad Agency Announcement on www.FedBizOpps.gov calling for the submission of white papers that cover: oil sensing improvements to response and detection; oil wellhead control and submerged oil response; traditional oil spill response technologies; alternative oil spill response technologies; and oil spill damage assessment and restoration.

The IATAP and the RDC will screen and triage submissions based on technical feasibility efficacy and deployability.  This will be a federal process to ensure a fair, systematic, responsive and accountable review of alternative response technologies by interagency experts.

The IATAP and RDC initial screening will result in one of three determinations: the white paper has a potential for immediate benefit to the oil spill response effort; the white paper submission needs more detailed investigation or evaluation by the appropriate government agency; or the white paper submission does not support this incident.

Key contact numbers

  • Report oiled shoreline or request volunteer information: (866) 448-5816
  • Submit alternative response technology, services or products: (281) 366-5511
  • Submit your vessel for the Vessel of Opportunity Program: (281) 366-5511
  • Submit a claim for damages: (800) 440-0858
  • Report oiled wildlife: (866) 557-1401
  • Medical support hotline:  (888) 623-0287

For information about the response effort, visit the Deepwater Horizon Response website.

Check out these other posts:

  • louise smith

    i am most grateful and thankful for all the work the coast guard and hired workers are doing—i have recently seen a demo of DRIED PEAT MOSS SPRINKLED over any place where there is oil, and it doesn’t get hard, as in concrete, but hard, enough to hold together when scooped up, with almost no residue left on the pick up item, or the ground or in the water–I KNOW THIS MAY BE TOO SIMPLE, but wouldn’t that be easier to deal with????

  • William Ashby

    Fabricate a modified top flange assembly for the top part of the flange on the blow out preventer. This fabrication would contain a shut off valve. Remove the damaged top flange and pipe and replace with the modified top flange which contains the shut off valve. Leave the valve in the open position until flange is bolted down and sealed, then close the valve.

  • http://ebook-blog.org/ ebook leser

    Environmental disaster in the Gulf of Mexico: The drilling rig leased by the oil company BP Deepwater Horizon was on 22 April sunk after an explosion, since large quantities of crude oil to flow from several leaks. The oil is now threatening the ecologically sensitive Mississippi Delta to damage sustained. I am disappointed that not a single one of the culprits in jail.

  • Tina Powers

    This is from my uncle; I thought it was worth passing on even though I have no idea about the feasibility.

    I am retired, and have spent most of my life repairing mechanical problems. I keep watching the gulf oil spill coverage on TV, and wonder if any one is thinking about simple ways to stop the oil. I, needless to say have never worked a mile under the sea, but see a way to stop the leak. I just don’t know who to tell.

    I believe if they would unbolt the exit flange on the blow out preventer and remove it, a gate valve could be bolted on in its place. While installing this valve it should remain open. After installation is complete this valve could be closed, and should stop 100% of the oil leaking out.

  • John Whalen

    develop a device similar to a cardiac surgions baloon angioplasty tube. insert into the well casing and inflate. or a device similar to that which water well drillers use to hydrofracture a well. it is a pipe inserted into the casing with an inflatable plug to seal the casing, then they pump water under high pressure to seas the well. concrete could be pumped in place of water. these should not be too hard to quickily fabricate.

  • http://www.mahercor.com Mark Picot

    Now that the cap is capturing oil, would it create more of a vacum if the tube transfering the oil from the seafloor to the surface tanker were heated. Using a coil wrap around the tube and heating it should break down the sludge like oil and make it rise more quickly, drawing more oil into the tanker. This may already be underway, but I haven’t heard of it yet.

  • L. Ellis

    Skimmers arent as effective with there partial cotainment.

    Weapons of war that arent bieng used must now be used for peace and good will towards man. Utility craft for beach landings must be used. To correct what is wrong with BP oil spill and prove that a weapon of war can be used for PEACE.

    The Department of Defense has beach landing craft that can be retroffited with wood pallets placed on there decks nailed together and secured with chains that will allow the oil to be captured or “stuck onto” the pallets themselves……IF the forward gate was left open and driven into and in line with the surface oil sludge floating in large linear masses. The opposite end of the craft can be cutt away to allow water flow from end to end. There are several models that can be used: BMC Higgins, LCM 8,LCU 2000, LCM3, There many utility craft that can be retrofitted.

    The pallets collect the sludge, remove the pallets, install and secure more pallets. The correct boat that allows the gate to be lowered allowing water to flow from end to end and off the deck will work….modify the deck, modify the rear and forward water flow.

  • Oliver Stubblefield

    I have a solution to capture even more oil than the apparutus they have. I have the design in rough draft but the concept is complete. The department in charge can contact me to put an agreement in place to aquire the design.

  • Tim Burkhart

    The oil needs to be stopped at it’s source now and cleanup is another issue.

    I have two ideas that I know will work, they may be used together for redundancy. The first uses an expanding device that grabs onto the internal diameter of the oil pipe. It uses an expanding set of three “feet” that are attached to a rotating threaded shaft which can be directed into place by a set of ROV’s. As the shaft rotates, the feet spread inside the pipe and grab onto the side walls. A hydraulic ram or electric servomotor could lock the feet into place. The use of three feet helps the grabbing mechanism deal with any out of round condition and discontinuity in the side walls. This inserted mechanism provides very little impedence to the oil flow since it is only a small diameter threaded rod, some attachment hardware and polymer (or other appropriate gripping surface) feet. Once the gripping device is inserted and locked, the only thing extending out of the pipe is a threaded rod which would have a cone shaped plug attached to it that is to be rotated down onto the pipe termination.

    Additionally, a large channeling tube similar to a drinking straw could be placed around the site and anchored at the bottom of the sea. This could be made out of a tough material bonded together like Tyvek house wrap or a ripstop nylon product similar to that used in hot air balloons. This method is used only for containment and yes, it will need to be a mile long. The tube would fit outside the oil flow, so getting it into place using ROV’s should be easier than some other methods of containment. The tube would need to extend from the bottom of the sea to the surface. At the surface, tankers would pump crude from the top of the tube before it could spill out into the surrounding sea.

    I am an engineer and a fisherman. I want this mess stopped for all of us!

  • Gregory King

    One week post-platform disaster I called BP to suggest that a 3-to-4 inch diameter pipe/hose be inserted deep inside the leaking well pipe (at least 300 feet or more) and that then large quantities of liquid nitrogen be pumped into the well at very high pressure. Said pumping of liquid nitrogen would continue as the pipe/hose is withdrawn from the well. This process should freeze all materials moving through the well casing, hopefully to such a point that heavy cement can then be pumped in atop the frozen block to seal the well permanently. Granted, I’m no engineer in fluid dynamics, but seems to me that if you get the well cold enough it might just stop gushing. Further, liquid nitrogen is non-toxic and poses no threat to the environment… other than maybe attracting the odd penguin or two. I pray you folks get this tragedy solved quickly. Good luck.

  • Martin

    I have watched this disaster from the beginning, I have a possible solution ,I sent it to BP but have not been heard anything but a form letter.
    As I see the unit at the bottom of the Gulf, BP cut the pipe which connected the riser to the oil rig.
    Just below the pipe cutting there is a flange fitting with several bolts around it, very typical and used in many oil, water, air applications.
    So here is my suggestion, why can’t BP not un bolt the flange, this would remove the cut pipe portion of the riser, then BP would be very free to attach a new flange style a ball valve or in fact any type of valve.the valve would be installed open , then closed once secure, they could also have re attached the pipe to the surface….they have the tools they have the equipment , I have included and example of a flange style valve, why is BP waiting this could have been done weeks ago..

  • http://none.com Steve bwick

    Dont act against the pressure-act with it…create a pipe larger and wider than the one the oil comes out of starting from the sea floor and surrounding the current pipe..add one section after another until the pipe is way above the point of oil release…the higher you go the less the pressure and higher the temperature…slowly taper the width of the pipe until you are high enough and have a narrow enough opening to attach a hose and pump the oil to ships on the surface.

  • http://www.planetresource.net/Gulf_Spill_Animation.html stevon john

    Planetresource.net has a Eco friendly solution to clean up the tragedy British Petroleum has created, please watch the video animation:
    and pass this along to as many people as you know.

    One person can still make a difference in this world, is that simple interactions have a rippling effect. Each time this gets pass along, the hope in cleaning our planet is passed on.

  • http://www.doreymedia.com Dave Dorey

    I’ve heard a lot of people finding fault with the way BP ran it’s drilling operation but are all the other deep rigs with US companies being scrutinized for safe practice now too? Including looking back at how they have been working, because I am sure there will be others who have taken the same risks and need to be exposed too.

DoDLive on Tumblr

  • photo from Tumblr

    While flying over Colorado a B-2 Stealth Bomber from Whiteman Air Force Base, MO, moves into position for a mid-air refueling via the boom of a KC-135R Stratotanker from the 128th Air Refueling Wing, Milwaukee on 09 May, 2012. The B-2 Stealth bomber and the KC-135 crews conducted the aerial refueling to maintain mission readiness standards.

    U.S. Air Force photo by Staff Sgt Jeremy M. Wilson (DVIDS)


  • photo from Tumblr

    Royal Canadian Mounted Police assigned to a Marine Security Emergency Response Team debark from the HMCS Ville de Quebec (FFH 332) to conduct boarding operations during Exercise Frontier Sentinel 2012 May 8, 2012 at sea off Sydney, Nova Scotia. Exercise Frontier Sentinel is a combined interagency exercise involving Joint Task Force Atlantic, the U.S. Coast Guard and the U.S. Navy Fleet Forces Command. The exercise is designed to continue to develop and validate the existing plans, treaties and standard operation procedures for a bilateral response to maritime homeland defense and security threats.

    (U.S. Navy photo by Mass Communication Specialist 2nd Class Ernesto Hernandez Fonte / Released) (DVIDS)


  • photo from Tumblr

    Explosive Ordnance Disposal technicians from the 380th Expeditionary Civil Engineer Squadron, tread water during water training in Southwest Asia, May 7, 2012. Members of the EOD flight use water training as part of their physical training routine to stay in top physical condition and stay trained.

    (U.S. Air Force photo by Staff Sgt. Sara Csurilla) (DVIDS)